Browsing Working Papers (DBP) by Author "John, Ruth"
Now showing items 1-2 of 2
-
Concepts, research design and methodologiesPonte, Stefano; Noe, Christine; Kweka, Opportuna; Mshale, Baruani; Sulle, Emmanuel; Brockington, Daniel; Kalumanga, Elikana; Minja, Rasul Ahmed; Budeanu, Adriana; Mwamfupe, Asubisye; Henriksen, Lasse Folke; Olwig, Mette Fog; Silvano, Pilly; Namkesa, Faraja; John, Ruth; Katikiro, Robert; Mabele, Mathew Bukhi (Frederiksberg, 2017)[More information][Less information]
Abstract: New and more complex partnerships are emerging to address the sustainability of natural resource use in developing countries. These partnerships variously link donors, governments, community-based organizations, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), business, certification agencies and other intermediaries. High expectations and many resources have been invested in these initiatives. Yet, we still do not know whether more sophisticated organizational structures, more stakeholders involved, and more advanced participatory processes have delivered better sustainability outcomes, and if so, in what sectors and under what circumstances. To fill this knowledge gap and build capacity in this area, the NEPSUS research and capacity building project assembles a multidisciplinary team to analyze sustainability partnerships in three key natural resource sectors in Tanzania: forestry, wildlife and coastal resources. In each of these sectors, we assess whether co-management with local communities and private and civil society actors, and putatively more participatory processes in the governance of renewable resources, result in more equitable and sustainable livelihoods and environmental outcomes. We compare ‘more complex’ partnerships to relatively ‘simpler’, more traditional top-down and centralized management systems, and to instances where sustainability partnerships are not in place. This working paper tackles the main conceptual, methodological and research design issues arising in this effort. URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10398/9548 Files in this item: 1
NEPSUS WP 2017 1.pdf (1.097Mb) -
A literature reviewNoe, Christine; Budeanu, Adriana; Sulle, Emmanuel; Olwig, Mette Fog; Brockington, Dan; John, Ruth (Frederiksberg, 2017)[More information][Less information]
Abstract: The rhetoric of a ‘win-win-win’ situation – which represents simultaneous achievement of economic growth, environmental protection and social development – is central to the emergence of community-based wildlife protection efforts that involve new partnerships between actors such as local communities, businesses and government agencies. The win-win rhetoric furthers the logic that the more partners, the more wins – yet the current knowledge base lacks clear criteria for evaluating partnerships. This working paper uses political ecology as a conceptual lens to propose such criteria. We suggest examining partnerships not only based on their complexity, but also how they are formed and gain legitimacy in different contexts and how various partnership configurations engender particular kinds of ecological and socio-economic outcomes. Based on a review of the literature about partnerships and their impacts, and drawing on insights from Tanzania’s wildlife sector, we establish three groups of literature that emphasize the benefits of partnerships: one focusing on landscape conservation, another on governance reforms and the last on tourism related businesses. In these three groups of literature, partnerships are claimed to improve the effectiveness of biodiversity governance by securing land, facilitating local developments and by creating business links. Building on critiques from political ecology we conclude by questioning this win-win-win rhetoric arguing that partnerships only lead to wins for specific actors thereby indirectly aggravating local power struggles. They do so by supporting rent seeking and the rise of local elites while simultaneously concealing the marginalization of other actors and thereby effectively contributing to the continued loss of local land rights. URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10398/9603 Files in this item: 1
NEPSUS WP 2017 2.pdf (2.264Mb)
Now showing items 1-2 of 2